Lex Stolk’s June 19, 2024 shortlist of new watches under €5,000 features three very different choices: the understated, hand-wound Grand Seiko SBGW231; Frederique Constant’s green moonphase-and-date Manufacture Classic; and the limited-edition Breitling Avenger 42 Red Arrows. It is a dated editorial selection—not a current, exhaustive ranking—and its euro prices should be read as historical rather than today’s offers.
What Lex Stolk’s shortlist covers
Stolk set out to choose brand-new watches from well-respected brands, without relying on pre-owned alternatives. The result spans a compact dress watch, a dressier complication and a more assertive aviation-inspired sports watch. The picks are best compared by style, movement and stated specifications, not treated as three interchangeable ways to spend the same budget.
His original framing was: “No pre-owned shortcuts, just brand-new watches; that was my mantra when putting together my edition of The Best Watches Under €5,000.” Read Stolk’s June 19, 2024 article at Fratello.
At a glance
| Watch | Character | Movement and reserve | Case and water resistance | Price and availability context |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grand Seiko SBGW231 | Restrained, hand-wound dress watch | Manual wind; reserve not stated in Stolk’s article | 37.3 × 44.3 × 11.6 mm; water resistance not stated in the article | €4,600 in the June 2024 article; current regional price and stock not established |
| Frederique Constant FC-716GR3H6 | Green moonphase and hand-indicated date | Automatic FC-716; 72-hour reserve | 40 mm, 11.78 mm thick; 5 ATM | €3,895 in the June 2024 article; the current official EU page lists the reference but did not show a euro price in the retrieved text |
| Breitling Avenger 42 Red Arrows A173281A1C1A1 | Bold aviation-inspired limited edition | Automatic Breitling 17; approximately 38-hour reserve | 42 mm; 300 m water resistance | £3,950 including VAT on Breitling’s UK page; limited to 360 pieces |
Specifications and historic prices for the first two columns and the 2024 price references come from Stolk’s June 2024 selection. Current Frederique Constant specifications are from its official EU product listing, and current UK Breitling details are from the official UK listing.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →#1 Best Overall
Grand Seiko SBGW231: a quiet, hand-wound dress watch
Stolk’s first pick is the SBGW231 from Grand Seiko’s Elegance Collection. Its appeal is restraint: a round case and understated dial leave the attention to the details, including Zaratsu-polished surfaces and finely finished hands and indexes. Stolk preferred it on a different strap from the one supplied, and noted that the budget allowed room for a replacement.
The article gives dimensions of 37.3 × 44.3 × 11.6 mm and a June 2024 price of €4,600. Those are historical figures, not a current quote. Current regional pricing and availability were not established, so check with Grand Seiko or an authorized retailer before treating the model as obtainable at that price.
Rank #2
- PROFESSIONAL DIVE PERFORMANCE – Water-resistant up to 600 m / 2,000 ft for demanding underwater use.
- POWERMATIC 80 MOVEMENT – Swiss automatic movement with up to 80 hours of power reserve.
- CERAMIC ROTATING BEZEL – Features a durable ceramic bezel ring with an anti-clockwise rotating bezel.
- SAPPHIRE CRYSTAL – Domed scratch-resistant sapphire crystal with antireflective coating for enhanced clarity.
- BUILT FOR ADVENTURE – Stainless steel case, screw-down crown, helium valve, and durable black rubber strap.
Frederique Constant FC-716GR3H6: green dial, moonphase and date
The Manufacture Classic Moonphase Date brings the most visible dial color of the three picks: a green sunray finish paired with a moonphase display and hand-indicated date. Stolk’s 2024 article identifies the reference as FC-716GR3H6, notes its 40 mm case—down from a 42 mm predecessor—and reports a €3,895 price at the time.
Frederique Constant’s official EU listing currently identifies the same reference with a 40 mm stainless-steel case, 11.78 mm thickness, 5 ATM water resistance and 20 mm lug width. It specifies an automatic FC-716 calibre with a 72-hour power reserve, moonphase, hand-indicated date and a five-year warranty. The page showed dispatch within five days when accessed, but that estimate can change; it did not show a euro price in the retrieved listing. The 2024 €3,895 figure should therefore not be read as today’s price.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Rank #3
- Discover the future of modern design. The BOLD Collection is defined by unexpected materials, vibrant colors, and a dynamic aesthetic.
- The BOLD Fusion Automatic features a bold, sporty case with a modern edge. This 44mm watch has a black exhibition dial, yellow goldtone centerzone, Swiss Super-LumiNova accents, and an automatic movement with an exhibition case back.
- Automatic watch: These timepieces are powered by the movement of the wrist, without the need for any external power source.
- Caring for your timepiece: Your Movado watch has been crafted with exceptional attention to quality, function, and detail. We recommend a maintenance interval of 3 to 5 years to ensure optimal performance. Avoid opening the watch yourself for any adjustments.
- Water Resistant: Up to 50m (165ft): Wearable for short periods of recreational swimming and showering, but not diving or snorkeling; 5 ATM.
Breitling Avenger 42 Red Arrows: a limited aviation-inspired sports watch
The Breitling brings the strongest sports-watch profile: a blue-and-black dial, Red Arrows insignia, steel case and automatic Breitling 17 movement. Stolk’s June 2024 article reports dimensions of 42 × 51.2 × 12.1 mm, 300 m water resistance, approximately 38 hours of reserve and a 360-piece edition. It also says that a percentage of sales goes to the Royal Air Force Benevolent Fund.
Stolk listed £3,900 on bracelet and £3,650 on blue leather; his €4,615 conversion of the bracelet price applied specifically to June 19, 2024. Breitling’s official UK listing now shows £3,950 including VAT for the exact reference, confirms the 360-piece limit and the charitable contribution, and specifies a 42 mm case, 12.15 mm thickness, 300 m water resistance and approximately 38-hour reserve. The UK list price is not a current euro price and does not establish stock in other markets.
Rank #4
- Case Size: 40.00 millimeter; Band Width: 12 millimeter; Case Thickness: 10.40 millimeter
- Swiss quartz movement, 316L stainless steel case, Index dial type, date
- Stainless steel bracelet, butterfly clasp with push-buttons closure
- Water-resistant up to a pressure of 10 bar (100 meter / 330 feet): Suitable for short periods of recreational swimming and showering, but no diving or snorkeling.
Which pick fits your priorities?
- Choose the Grand Seiko for understated dress-watch character. Its hand-wound format, modest stated dimensions and carefully finished surfaces make it the most restrained option. Current stock and regional price need checking.
- Choose the Frederique Constant for a dial-side complication. It combines a moonphase and date with a 72-hour reserve, while its official EU listing provides current specifications and warranty information.
- Choose the Breitling for a more robust sports-watch specification and limited-edition identity. Its 300 m rating and 360-piece run distinguish it from the other two; its verified current price here is in the UK market, not euros.
Water-resistance figures are not equivalent: the Frederique Constant is rated at 5 ATM and the Breitling at 300 m, while the cited article does not state a water-resistance figure for the Grand Seiko. Do not infer the same water-use suitability across all three.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.How to read the budget figures
The shortlist’s euro prices belong to June 2024: €4,600 for the Grand Seiko, €3,895 for the Frederique Constant and a converted €4,615 for the Breitling bracelet version. They are useful as a record of Stolk’s selection at that date, not as current buying prices. The currently listed Breitling figure above is a UK price, while the Frederique Constant page is an EU listing without a displayed euro price; these are not like-for-like regional offers.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteBest Value
- Case Size: 40.00 mm, Band Width: 20, Case Thickness: 8.25 mm
- Quartz movement, 316L stainless steel case, Index dial type, Date, SuperLuminova-coated hands, enabling precise reading even in the dark, EOL (battery end-of-life indicator).
- Stainless steel strap/bracelet, interchangeable quick release bracelet, butterfly clasp with push-buttons closure
- Water-resistant up to a pressure of 10 bar (100 m / 330 ft): suitable for short periods of recreational swimming and showering, but no diving or snorkeling.
- 2 Year International Warranty
For a purchase decision, confirm the exact reference, country-specific price, taxes, stock and warranty terms with the brand or an authorized local retailer. The shortlist itself is not an exhaustive survey of every new watch below €5,000.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
